Dynasty Dilemmas - Romo vs Eli

[Jaysports]

Who would you rather have for the next 3 years and why?

[ravage]

Romo is not the QB I would want for my NFL team if I had to choose but for fantasy he is a very good QB. Manning pops up every couple of years and then has a bad year or two. Romo is a consistant mid-#1 fantasy QB. I'd go Romo here.

[Chordotomy]

Romo. Consistent QB1 numbers. While I expect a bit of a rebound from Eli, he doesn't sling it like Romo does and both turn the ball over a fair amount. They aren't light years apart, but I'll take Romo 10 times out of 10 in this discussion. Glad I'm not a Cowboys fan, though.

[Burgandy]

Romo is my bromo yo.....

[League of Shadows]

Same tier.
I have Romo slightly ahead of Eli, though I like Eli's weapons better; so if they don't add a rb and keep the Black unicorn i may change my mind.

[Thurmans Hermit]

Eli. No question. I've never owned Romo and never will.